Kralik spatter glass vase or Gebruder Funk & Co or E. Steinwald or...? | ||
| aghcollect's loves197 of 44577 |  |  |
kwqd loves this.
larksel loves this.
Newfld loves this.
Vintagefran loves this.
EZa loves this.
katherinescollections loves this.
antiquerose loves this.
MamaT loves this.
martika loves this.
aura loves this.
philmac51 loves this.
Moonstonelover21 loves this.
SEAN68 loves this.
getthatmonkeyoutofme loves this.
smiata loves this.
Michelleb007 loves this.CardinalLady loves this.
Rick55 loves this.
ozmarty loves this.
racer4four loves this.
blunderbuss2 loves this.
mikelv85 loves this.
aghcollect loves this.
welzebub loves this.
vetraio50 loves this.
Alan2310 loves this.Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate
Posted 9 years ago
Ivonne
(186 items)
Judging by the shape I'd say it's Kralik (like the satin vase posted on CW some time ago) ,but it also reminds F.Koudelka vase.His vase has a longer neck although.
Any opinions will be apreciated.
Thanks for looking!
Create an account or login in order to post a comment.
A lovely vase, Ivonne.....I particularly like the shape.
I'm glad you like it.I like the shape too.Thanks for the comment :-)
Thank you Alan,vetraio,welzebub,Moonstonelover,aghcollect,katherinescollections,mikelv,Michelle and blunderbuss for the loves :-)
Love the Blues -- and hues of it !! Great Find!!
Thank you Karen and Rose for the love and Rose for the nice comment !
Thanks,ozmarty for the love :-)
Lovely vase Ivonne... I love the colors!
Thanks,Rick :-) Blue and yellow always look good,they're so natural combo.
Thank you CardinalLady for the love :-)
Hi,Mary,glad to hear from you!
This piece I got on a Czech auction site .I have to find the shop you saw in W-w.I'll do it when I get back from Greece.We're leaving on Tuesday.
I'm happy you have great memories despite having so bad weather :-)
Ah,this is the very first picture I'v seen in my life!Iwas a child and was so impressed that never forgot it and as an adult bought an album of Memling's Last Judgment.
Thanks Mary for your lovely comment :-)
Thanks SEAN for the love:-)
Thanks smiata for the love:-)
Thanks aura and getthatmonkey for the loves.
Hello Ivonne!
Did you find out the maker in the meantime and/or could you confirm your Kralik suspect? I am asking because i have a small vase here with the same colours and your vase is the only one in the web i found with these colours :-)
Regards
Micha
Hi,Micha!No,I didn't confirm Kralik attribution and I should change the title,because I confirmed Gebr.Funk as the makers.I found this vase searching internet and the colours are exactly the same like in my vase.The shape is different though but colours are exactly the same,also their arrangement and the size of spatter.Can you post your vase to compare? This is the link which I considered as helpful:
http://www.glaskilian.de/Vase-Glasfabrik-Gebrueder-Funk.1110+B6YmFja1BJRD0xMTEwJnByb2R1Y3RJRD0xMzEzNCZwaWRfcHJvZHVjdD0xMTEwJmRldGFpbD0_.0.html
Hi Ivonne!
Thank you for your quick response!
My vase is identical to the vase shown on the glaskilian website.
The colours of my vase seem to be a little bit brighter as the colours of the glaskilian vase. I will now continue to research, will try to find a second proof for being it really made by Funk. I always have doubts if i only have one attribution. Will tell here when i find one :-)
Regards
Micha
True kralik and Jan Killians vase is true Funk
Thanks kralik1928 for your input.I'll take it under consideration.
I think it could be Ernst Steinwald. The type and technique of design is very similar, for example, to this vase: https://www.collectorsweekly.com/stories/295779-czech-art-glass--kralik-bambus-vase?in=442-activity
nebo: https://www.bohemianglass.org/katalog/vaza-bambus-968/detail/
Thank you,larksel for your input.I 've already noticed this being on your website,but I haven't time to look through my posts and write about new ids.I think there are more false ids in my posts according to the new attribution discoveries.
When comparing shapes as part of the process to see if an attribution can be reasonably made, it is most important to pay attention to smaller details regarding the shapes. IN the link below I have put this vase and the suggest Bambus shape side by side. Although the proportions and general shape can be seen as similar, what sticks out to me are the differences. For the purpose of attributions, these differences take on a much greater meaning.
The body of each vase is actually a slightly different shape, with this vase having more of a spherical or round appearance, while the Bambus piece has a lower body which is much more ovoid in appearance. There is also a notable difference in the size and shape of the base, or foot of the piece. Where the Bambus example has a very pronounced foot, this vase does not.
Because of these differences, I am of the opinion that an attribution to the same maker could not be arrived at under these circumstances. Where some critics of my research claim that shapes can not be used in this manner because the methodology is fraught with errors, I am of the opinion that is not true, especially if the shapes are compared closely.
I am of the opinion that although these are similar shapes, they are not the same shape, and can not be linked to a common production house based on the shape.
http://www.kralik-glass.com/images/Image11.jpg
I think that the shape is very similar, but mainly the technique of decor is, in my opinion, very similar, if not the same as the ground for a Bambus vase. This is how I see this from a photo and a comparison with my similar Bambus vases.
The decor on this vase and the others is a 3 color spatter glass on a clear ground. Likely a type of spatter that any number of houses made. I think the link to a possible attribution could be made if the same shape as in this post were found in a Bambus decor, or if the same shape as a Bambus piece was found with this decor.
Based on a multi colored spatter using a different mix of colors on a clear ground, and only similar shapes, I think the leap to a common maker is too far to be supportable with these examples. I think the differences in the shapes are much more noteworthy for the purpose of attribution than the similarities. Just my humble opinion.
I'm not saying it's definitely Steinwald. I said I thought it might be Steinwald. The shapes are very similar and stylistically similar to other Steinwald shapes known in Bambus or Flowerall decors. But the truth is that it would like to have both vases really next to each other and touch them.
Gentlemen,thank you for your deepened opinions and interesting discussion.In my opinion some attributions will be never identified.In this case the spatter decor is quite distinctive - blue,yellow and oxblood in clear glass.I've never seen another sample of this spatter.