Share your favorites on Show & Tell

2009 unc. 1/2 doller from mint set D vs P thickness disparity

In Stamps > Errors Freaks and Oddities > Show & Tell.
Unsolved mystery items12815 of 96522Mirror Black Vase with Matisse Design by NoritakeSPF&Co 18B wood stove. 08-20-22
1
Love it
0
Like it

fortapachefortapache loves this.
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.


    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate


    Posted 5 years ago

    M2limited
    (1 item)

    Can anyone provide insight into why several of the Pennsylvania minted 1/2 dollers from the 2009 uncirculated 36pc mint set mesure .15mm less in thickness and have a weight differance of just under 1/10 gram? Many of the Pen. 1/2 dollars also appear to have been struck with noticeably less pressure leading to a flatter appearance that I found nearly impossible to photograph. The thickness differance is visualy notable in the photos I provided. photos can be deceiving as can our eyes which is why I have included the micrometer shots. The stated thickness I have found to be standard, gleaned from several numismatic sites, for this coin is 2.15mm and to the best of my knowledge/reasearch ablility there have been no published changes to the coins dementions since 1970.

    These 2 coins came from the same 36 coin set. I have found 10 such sets all of which the denver coin unwaveringly measures at 2.15mm thick. Inexplicably, the PA coins vary from 1.98-2.04mm.

    Thoughts?

    Best Regards,

    Matt

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    logo
    Errors Freaks and Oddities
    See all
    drbobstamps US Scott #505 Mint NH OG Sound Stamp in Middle Block of 9 SCV $1000
    drbobstamps US Scott #505 Mint NH O...
    $324
    NobleSpirit } US Legends of the West Recalled Error Sheet
    NobleSpirit } US Legends of the Wes...
    $22
    U.S. EFO SC# 1608 MISPERFORATION AND COLOR SHIFT ERROR 2 STAMP ERRORS
    U.S. EFO SC# 1608 MISPERFORATION AN...
    $20
    #721c mint original gum never hinged IMPERF pair
    #721c mint original gum never hinge...
    $22
    logo
    drbobstamps US Scott #505 Mint NH OG Sound Stamp in Middle Block of 9 SCV $1000
    drbobstamps US Scott #505 Mint NH O...
    $324
    See all

    Comments

    1. M2limited M2limited, 5 years ago
      As an odd addition to this post, please take a look at my profile , picture as it shows the dollar coins that came with the sets. Notice the weaker Pennsylvania strike vs. The almost over striking seen from Denver's?

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.