Share your favorites on Show & Tell

Found this in family photos.

In Photographs > Show & Tell.
Alfred1o1's loves43 of 211Butler Fifth Ave birdbath brooch ULRICA HYDMAN-VALLIEN 'BIRDEE' - 98962
7
Love it
0
Like it

Alfred1o1Alfred1o1 loves this.
kwqdkwqd loves this.
blunderbuss2blunderbuss2 loves this.
RichmondLoriRichmondLori loves this.
truthordaretruthordare loves this.
fortapachefortapache loves this.
dav2no1dav2no1 loves this.
See 5 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.


    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate


    Posted 4 years ago

    Law
    (1 item)

    My Grandfather is in this photo. I have been trying to find out what this group is. I have struck out. Can you help? I do know he was a Mason, but there no Freemason insignia’s in this photo.

    Lisa Watkins

    Unsolved Mystery

    Help us close this case. Add your knowledge below.

    logo
    Photographs
    See all
    1860s CIVIL WAR TINTYPE PHOTO DOUBLE ARMED UNION SOLDIER COLT REVOLVER & KNIFE
    1860s CIVIL WAR TINTYPE PHOTO DOUBL...
    $175
    1/6 PLATE DAGUERREOTYPE TWO YOUNG MEN W/ TOP HATS + CIGARS, NOTE: HAS SCRATCHES
    1/6 PLATE DAGUERREOTYPE TWO YOUNG M...
    $105
    1850s DAGUERREOTYPE / AMBROTYPE PHOTO WALL FRAME - OGEE STYLE ROSEWOOD VENEER
    1850s DAGUERREOTYPE / AMBROTYPE PHO...
    $115
    Glass Ambrotype 1850s-60s 2 men in hat & top hat back to back an unusual photo
    Glass Ambrotype 1850s-60s 2 men in ...
    $475
    logo
    1860s CIVIL WAR TINTYPE PHOTO DOUBLE ARMED UNION SOLDIER COLT REVOLVER & KNIFE
    1860s CIVIL WAR TINTYPE PHOTO DOUBL...
    $175
    See all

    Comments

    1. dav2no1 dav2no1, 4 years ago
      Just a guess but there's a skull on the table and they're in some crazy costumes. So maybe Odd Fellows?
    2. flashlarue flashlarue, 4 years ago
      5 axes on the floor and 1 axe on the table. Only group I know to use an axe as a symbol is Woodsmen Of the World, WOW. But I have never seen them in robes.
    3. RichmondLori RichmondLori, 4 years ago
      the one group known for the robes ....well lets just say I don't see any flames or crosses....but I am no expert..
    4. RichmondLori RichmondLori, 4 years ago
      Please don't take my comment in the wrong way. I meant nothing bad or suggestive. ! Can't delete - but if I could I would. (Late night comments should be edited). Lori
    5. blunderbuss2 blunderbuss2, 4 years ago
      Don't think they are selling Girl Scout cookies ! LOL
    6. Law, 4 years ago
      Lori, no offense taken. That was the second thing I looked into. ????
    7. Law, 4 years ago
      Thanks, tried the odd fellows, don’t think it is that, or scouts. Lol
    8. neat.old.stuff neat.old.stuff, 4 years ago
      Wow, don't think I love it, but sure makes me curious what it's all about. Very interesting.
    9. blunderbuss2 blunderbuss2, 4 years ago
      Early group of Hare Krishnars ?
    10. Alfred1o1 Alfred1o1, 4 years ago
      looks like..... The Shepherd's Crook: From the Star to the Cross organization...??
    11. Alfred1o1 Alfred1o1, 4 years ago
      shiners doing degree work...? they dress up for it ....something to see....
    12. keramikos, 4 years ago
      Hi, Law. :-)

      I think it could well be Odd Fellows. The shepherd's crook was indeed one of their symbols:

      *snip*

      The crook, as the “staff of the shepherd,” is associated with the Odd Fellows Encampment Degrees. These degrees have rituals that tell stories of a shepherd’s life. The curved head is used to reach after and draw a member back to safety as part of the ritual. The members recognize the crook as a symbol of watchful care, which they are expected to exhibit toward other members, family, friends, and their community.

      *snip*

      http://collection.folkartmuseum.org/objects/5131/independent-order-of-odd-fellows-crook

      https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Detail,_Odd_Fellows_Temple,_7th_Street,_San_Francisco,_California.jpg

      And they did have various costumes (see third image at this Worthpoint listing for a 1943 edition of the C.E. Ward Company catalog of IOOF regalia):

      *snip*

      Here is an April 1943 C E Ward Company Catalog of Odd Fellow Costumes, Collars and Supplies . In 1891 Clyde E. Ward and his brother in law, Ed Stilson, paid four New London gentlemen $138 for their lodge rosette business. Shortly after this they received an order from the Odd Fellows Lodge for 600 bullion collars and the Ward-Stilson Company was on its way. Mr. Ward had a gentleman from Columbus come up and show the two women on a treadle sewing machine how to do the bullion work since this was all new to them. They later added caps, robes, swords and other lodge paraphernalia.

      *snip*

      https://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/1943-e-ward-co-ioof-catalog-costumes-1813412248
    13. keramikos, 4 years ago
      Whoops, I forgot to address the axes:

      *snip*

      In many lodges it is customary to collect donations for the needy and distressed on the Warden’s axe, which has painted on the side presented for the donation the expressive Heart in Hand –Grosh’s Manual p.104

      *snip*

      https://oddfellowsguide.com/2017/11/10/the-wardens-axe/
    14. Law, 4 years ago
      Keramikos... Thank you. I think I have been too hung up on the robes. After the links you sent, I think you are onto something.
    15. dav2no1 dav2no1, 4 years ago
      What's with the guy on the far right, thats not in costume?
    16. keramikos, 4 years ago
      Law, You're welcome. :-)

      I too was hung up on the robes, and because of it felt dubious about them being Odd Fellows until I tripped on various editions of that catalog. I like the one at Worthpoint because it's unambiguously dated, and as such is a pretty good match for that U.S. flag with forty-eight stars in the background of the picture.

      Here is some background on Odd Fellows and human bones:

      https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/odd-fellows-found-skeletons
    17. keramikos, 4 years ago
      dav2no1, I noticed him, too. Maybe his costume was at the cleaners. };-)
    18. blunderbuss2 blunderbuss2, 4 years ago
      Maybe their parole officer. LOL
    19. keramikos, 4 years ago
      If you look closely at the skull, it appears not to be real. Apparently, IOOF was well-known for using real human skeletons, but some states have laws against that kind of use, so that may be the reason for the fake.

      Here's more on IOOF and skeletons:

      https://www.cultofweird.com/curiosities/odd-fellows-skeletons/

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.