Share your favorites on Show & Tell

HO Guage Boxcars Athearn And Mantua/Tyco

In Model Trains > Athearn Model Trains > Show & Tell and Model Trains > HO Scale Model Trains > Show & Tell.
Solved mystery items25 of 11848MINTONS AESOP’S FABLES BROWN TRANSFERWARE PLATE 8.5"1904 st Louis world fair souvenir Vaseline opalescent compote
15
Love it
0
Like it

LataLata loves this.
vetraio50vetraio50 loves this.
sherrilousherrilou loves this.
BronmarBronmar loves this.
Merrill33Merrill33 loves this.
dav2no1dav2no1 loves this.
mikelv85mikelv85 loves this.
fortapachefortapache loves this.
NewfldNewfld loves this.
elanskielanski loves this.
vcalvcal loves this.
BHIFOSBHIFOS loves this.
collectorpaulcollectorpaul loves this.
DejaVu2DejaVu2 loves this.
Vynil33rpmVynil33rpm loves this.
See 13 more
Add to collection

    Please create an account, or Log in here

    If you don't have an account, create one here.


    Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate


    Posted 5 months ago

    fortapache
    (3417 items)

    Here is a pair of boxcars by different manufacturers that show the difference in quality. The first is Athearn. It is a model of a wooden boxcar. Not quite as good as last week's but still fairly detailed. It is made up of several parts. The roof walkway, brake wheel, couplers, doors and base are all separate pieces. The other which is Mantua aka Tyco is almost a one piece casting. It is the body of the car with the doors and trucks being separate pieces. Even the couplers are connected to the trucks. I do like the graphics on it. It is a bit bright but I can fix that with a little weathering.
    Got one more boxcar to go.

    logo
    Athearn Model Trains
    See all
    Athearn HO Parts Lot of 24 Drive Bands Rubber Bands for Hi-F Locomotives Hustler
    Athearn HO Parts Lot of 24 Drive Ba...
    $3
    Walthers 933-822 Diesel Dress-Up Kit Fits Athearn F7/F9 A/B HO Scale Train
    Walthers 933-822 Diesel Dress-Up Ki...
    $10
    HO Drive Belt Rubber Band 25 Black! Hi-F Hustler RDC Plow F3 F7 GP9 ATH90101
    HO Drive Belt Rubber Band 25 Black!...
    $3
    Athearn ATHG67140 Genesis DC-21 Pin Motherboard for LEDs (1) HO Scale
    Athearn ATHG67140 Genesis DC-21 Pin...
    $19
    logo
    Athearn HO Parts Lot of 24 Drive Bands Rubber Bands for Hi-F Locomotives Hustler
    Athearn HO Parts Lot of 24 Drive Ba...
    $3
    See all

    Comments

    1. RVolskay RVolskay, 3 months ago
      That UP boxcar looks like a Marx. Athearn has always used a separate frame, that snaps into the shell of the car. Very nice find, in great shape!

    Want to post a comment?

    Create an account or login in order to post a comment.