Coin from the Nuestra Señora De Atocha | ||
| Alfred1o1's loves46 of 211 |  |  |
Alfred1o1 loves this.
Karenoke loves this.
Jono loves this.
RonM loves this.
tom61375 loves this.
DrFluffy loves this.
BHock45 loves this.
Lilliflunew loves this.
cwork likes this.Roycroftbooksfromme1 loves this.
epson233 loves this.
nldionne loves this.alanp loves this.
blunderbuss2 loves this.
Poop loves this.Create a Show & TellReport as inappropriate
Posted 12 years ago
NicoleJere…
(439 items)
Shown is a coin that was made from a certified silver bar (A340-85) that was on board the Nuestra Señora De Atocha. The ship sunk on September 6, 1622 near the Florida Keys. It was part of King Phillip IV of Spain's Tierra Firme Fleet. The ship was discovered by Mel Fisher's search team on July 20, 1985.
Create an account or login in order to post a comment.
very cool....
How much is it worth , it's beautiful?
" is a coin that was made from a certified silver bar (A340-85)" there for this coin is a copy worth only the metal value. If you can find some one who actually collects this type of thing (relic made) they may be willing to pay a premium. Good luck.
^ Art and artifacts are worth what people are willing to pay for them. Motto to live by in the art and museum industry, of which I am a part.
well its far more complicated , we have to assess if this a stray , a stray is in this situation is washed ashore
only certified Mel Fisher coins have decent value, and he is dead i believe 20 years or so, and the museum don,t give a damn , so it is not decent value
The highest classification is what they call a 3 point 1 certified
so the best this could be is a stray ,and then an awful lot of value is out of it, there are lot of strays by the way
if you see the qualification of a 3 point 1 they are in rather mediocre condition , but three point one !
i think this highly unlikely that this valuable, let,s say it very eufemistisch
its almost impossible to be in this mint pristine condition this way
well i think there is a correlation between beauty , and authenticity, and the market is not always right
Why am I being crucified for having what is probably a replica?? Lol. Nobody here is trying to conflate collectible and sentimental value.
Also I have a Masters in the field and a second one in the works- I do not need an explication as to how to assess value lol.
Plus your explanation doesn’t at all change the fact that things are worth what people are willing to pay for them. That is a literal saying in the field in which I hold my degrees and work professionally.
no i dont want to crucify you
your opinion is as follows, that was on board the Nuestra Señora De Atocha !!!!!
there is nothing wrong with a replica
and if you want to know , i got an PHD and that got nothing to do with skill , just not falling asleep in college and stamina
actually i am just a rooky in assessment , i was a powerseller in antiques and an actioneer for a long time at an rather respected auctionhouse, and i was a designer of a outdated spreadsheet on deviation in correction with significance of artifacts
That description is NOT my opinion. I merely transcribed the certificate that came with the coin, no more, no less. I don’t post opinions on here.
Of course, college degrees are not a reflection of emotional intelligence, only academic intelligence. We’re speaking about the latter, not the former, hence why I delineated my qualifications.
You have experience, and I’ve worked as a curator at a respected NYC museum as well as a cataloguer at a notable NYC auction house. We’re more alike than previously assumed.
where is the certificate,
and what do you think what is the value
The certificate is somewhere in my house LOL. Even if it’s authentic, which the certificate claims it to be, it still likely has little value due to lack of rarity.
you want the museum to arbitrate ? , we split the costs for the request , deal ?
Deal! Lol!